PunKZ Posted April 12, 2009 Doesn't hurt to brainstorm, you never know when ideas may be useful in the future. Case in point, the quad tower thread on the old, old forums had some ideas that made it into 4.0. Yeah, but you know I mean, when I first saw the Voodo tower in Eletd, my first thought was, oh, it has the same ability as Witch doctor, and when I saw Hydro tower I was thinking, oh this is reminding me of Tiny's Toss, I would like to have something that's unique for Eletd that reminds people that have played this game of eletd when they play other games. Go to top Share this post Link to post
jolin012 Posted April 12, 2009 afaik - we had hydro before they had kunkka for example... try to make ppl copy the ronald stage to their maps you mean? make icefrog replace roshan with ronald Go to top Share this post Link to post
Guest M45T3R Posted April 12, 2009 Doesn't hurt to brainstorm, you never know when ideas may be useful in the future. Case in point, the quad tower thread on the old, old forums had some ideas that made it into 4.0. Yeah, but you know I mean, when I first saw the Voodo tower in Eletd, my first thought was, oh, it has the same ability as Witch doctor, and when I saw Hydro tower I was thinking, oh this is reminding me of Tiny's Toss, I would like to have something that's unique for Eletd that reminds people that have played this game of eletd when they play other games. There's so much you can do with only Warcraft 3, so you can't complain. Plus, how are you so sure it's not the other way around, that DotA copied Eletd? Go to top Share this post Link to post
Karawasa Posted April 12, 2009 We most definitely had Erupt (Hyrdo Tower) first. It was actually suggested to me on the Wc3C forums. Go to top Share this post Link to post
PunKZ Posted April 13, 2009 There's so much you can do with only Warcraft 3, so you can't complain. Plus, how are you so sure it's not the other way around, that DotA copied Eletd? I don't think so, DotA was made long before Eletd even started. Go to top Share this post Link to post
Cisz Posted April 13, 2009 I don't think so, DotA was made long before Eletd even started. This is an unusual post, because you are wrong for once. Icefrog and Kara play a lot of eletd together, and they both have an eye on the other guys map, so it's very logical to expect they both copy each other. DotA has a long history of continiousl adding more content to the map, so DotA has changed a lot during the making of eletd. Also, kara just stated that: "We most definitely had Erupt (Hyrdo Tower) first." Go to top Share this post Link to post
PunKZ Posted April 13, 2009 I don't think so, DotA was made long before Eletd even started. This is an unusual post, because you are wrong for once. Icefrog and Kara play a lot of eletd together, and they both have an eye on the other guys map, so it's very logical to expect they both copy each other. DotA has a long history of continiousl adding more content to the map, so DotA has changed a lot during the making of eletd. Also, kara just stated that: "We most definitely had Erupt (Hyrdo Tower) first." But u still didn't prove me wrong, you know DotA was made long before eletd even started, we had euls and guinsoo before Icefrog too. So I guess I wasn't wrong about that exact post, and btw.. Didn't know that kara and ice played together Go to top Share this post Link to post
Twilice Posted April 13, 2009 But not with the same abilitys.... As with element td, dota also changed alot. Go to top Share this post Link to post
Karawasa Posted April 13, 2009 Remember, DotA = Defense of the Ancients. This is a map of the genre AoS (Aeon of Strife). Eul's AoS obviously came before Element TD, because it was on RoC (Reign of Chaos). Guinsoo's AoS (DotA) I'm not sure about, I'd have to see a release date. Icefrog's AoS (DotA too) we certainly came before. Go to top Share this post Link to post
PunKZ Posted April 14, 2009 Remember, DotA = Defense of the Ancients. This is a map of the genre AoS (Aeon of Strife). Eul's AoS obviously came before Element TD, because it was on RoC (Reign of Chaos). Guinsoo's AoS (DotA) I'm not sure about, I'd have to see a release date. Icefrog's AoS (DotA too) we certainly came before. kk, btw I love your sig Go to top Share this post Link to post